What Is a Fiduciary and Why Should You Care?
The quiet problem most investors miss
When you sit across from a financial professional, you assume they're working for you. They have your information, they're giving you advice, they're called an "advisor." Of course they're on your side.
But in many countries, financial professionals operate under different legal standards. Some are required to act in your best interest. Others are only required to recommend products that are "suitable"—a much lower bar that permits significant conflicts of interest.
How this actually works
Fiduciary standard: A fiduciary must put your interests ahead of their own. They must disclose conflicts of interest, seek the best available options for you, and cannot recommend products simply because they pay higher commissions.
Suitability standard: Under a suitability standard, an advisor only needs to recommend products that are "suitable" for your situation—not necessarily the best or cheapest. A product can be suitable while also being more expensive or generating higher commissions than alternatives.
The difference matters enormously. Under suitability, an advisor can recommend a fund with a 2% expense ratio when an equivalent fund charges 0.2%, as long as the expensive fund isn't completely inappropriate for your situation. Under fiduciary duty, they'd need to justify why the expensive option is better for you specifically.
Many financial professionals—bank salespeople, insurance agents, broker-dealer representatives—operate under suitability standards, not fiduciary standards. The title "advisor" doesn't guarantee fiduciary duty.
Where people get this wrong
Assuming all advisors are fiduciaries. The word "advisor" has no legal protection in most places. Someone calling themselves a financial advisor may have no fiduciary obligation to you.
Not asking directly. Many people feel awkward asking about their advisor's legal standard. But it's a reasonable question, and the answer matters.
Confusing credentials with standards. A financial professional might have impressive certifications but still operate under a suitability standard that permits conflicts of interest.
Trusting disclosures buried in paperwork. The standard under which someone operates is often disclosed in fine print that clients never read. Firms aren't required to make this obvious.
What to focus on instead
-
Ask directly: "Are you a fiduciary?" A genuine fiduciary will say yes clearly. Evasive answers or explanations about "suitability" are red flags.
-
Get it in writing. Ask for a written statement that the advisor will act as a fiduciary with respect to your accounts. If they won't provide this, they're probably not one.
-
Understand fee structures. Fee-only advisors (who charge flat fees or percentages of assets, with no commissions) have fewer conflicts than commission-based advisors. Fiduciary duty matters more when commissions create incentives.
-
Consider whether you need an advisor at all. For simple situations, low-cost index funds and automated investment platforms may serve you better than any advisor, fiduciary or not.
How this connects to long-term outcomes
The difference between fiduciary and suitability standards can mean tens of thousands of dollars over an investing lifetime. An advisor operating under suitability can legally recommend products that cost you 1% more per year in fees, compounding against you for decades.
This isn't to say all non-fiduciary advisors give bad advice. Many are ethical professionals who genuinely try to help clients. But the legal framework matters because it defines the minimum standard of care you're entitled to.
When you're trusting someone with your financial future, you deserve to know whose interests come first. If it's not legally required to be yours, make sure you understand why you're still choosing to work with them.
A title on a business card doesn't create obligation. A legal fiduciary duty does.